The Worst "Best" Book I’ve Ever Read

Suggested by Janet.

How about, “What’s the worst ‘best’ book you’ve ever read — the one everyone says is so great, but you can’t figure out why?”
***************************

I’ve read some bad books but I have a firm policy of ditching the book after 50 or so pages if it just isn’t doing it for me. However, for book group one month, we read Nobody True by James Herbert. James Herbert is Britain’s number one bestselling author of horror fiction. We had not really read anything from that genre so we gave it a try.

Boy, were we sorry.

The main character is murdered by a serial killer. BUT, and there is a big but, he is having an out-of-body experience when it happens so he comes back to his body only to find it, well dead. He goes through the story inhabiting other bodies so he can catch his killer. There is a lot of lurching around (think Igor or Dawn of the Dead) as he takes over body after body and then has to learn how to make everything work.

My book group was in tears discussing this! We were hysterical and I’m sure that was not Herbert’s intent, but the storyline was so ridiculous and it was just so far “out there”. I really just wanted to character to stay dead. We all did. If I had been reading it on a plane I would have popped the emergency hatch and called it a day. It was THAT bad.

I thought about reading another Herbert book to see if this particular book was just an oddity but after some time passed, I just can’t bring myself to do it. If anyone has read anything else by him and thinks I should give it a shot, let me know.

8 thoughts on “The Worst "Best" Book I’ve Ever Read”

  1. Actually I never read any books by this author and I don’t think I will consider him.. although your review is so funny I’m tempted to read this book just to see how bad it is.. opening the hatch of the emergency door, now that is hillarious 🙂

  2. Desert Rose, I DARE you to read it! If you do, we will have a good conversation about it afterward, that’s for sure!

  3. Easy question- the book I read and went “huh” is The Catcher in the Rye. Totally did not get it, found it incredibly boring.

  4. I’ve read a few self-pubs that were pretty bad. The last book that I gave up on that everyone sais was great was Atonement. It wasn’t terrible it just bored me.

Leave a reply to Lisa Cancel reply