Review: Things I Want My Daughters To Know

After a couple of power outages (insert snicker here) I finally managed to finish Things I Want My Daughters To Know by Elizabeth Noble. Barbara, who is dying of cancer decides to write letters to each of her daughters. These letters are shared with them after her death along with one of her journals. As you can imagine, these letters tell of her love for them, what she hopes they achieve in life and also a secret that she had been carrying with her for quite some time.

First off, there are many daughters to speak of. I was a bit distracted by the number of daughters. There are four of them. Jennifer is married to Stephen and it not happy with her marriage. She is uptight and prissy. Lisa is a bit more fluid. She is dating Andy, a really nice guy and she’s not sure where the relationship is going or if she even wants one with him. Amanda is the “wild child”. Always moving, always off to another country. I really liked Amanda. She meets Ed and we get to see a softer side to her. Hannah is the baby of the family at sixteen years of age and she is the product of Barbara’s second marriage to Mark. I don’t feel that Hannah’s character really came through for me. She seemed very one dimensional and flat. However, I adored Mark, Barbara’s second husband. He seemed almost too good to be true but a great guy to have in the family.

My main problem with this book is that I really did not like Barbara. I didn’t hate her, but I didn’t like her. Her letters were a bit on the shallow side and her decision to share her secret in that way… I did not approve of it. I “get” that parents can be flawed. I’m a parent and I am in no way perfect. Not even close, but the letters were not affectionate to me. Not really. They sort of made me feel as if Barbara was a bit of a coward. Writing letters about stuff that probably should have been shared in person.

At the end, I was left wondering whose story this was. I felt that Noble tried to give the characters equal time but in doing so, I never got to hear any one character’s voice to its fullest. I also felt the end was a bit rushed. As if tying up all the loose ends was an issue. I really would have liked to have heard this story through Mark’s voice. He was truly the anchor in all of this.

As for a book club pick, I could see this being discussed by a book club. There are lots of issues to debate and question and the development of some of the sisters was quite good and I wanted to know more about them.

I received this book from Jennifer over at Book Club Girl as part of her online radio show with the author which can be heard here. The copy of the book that I received has a reading guide in the back of it which has some really good questions and includes insight from the author. If you’ve read the book, let me know what you thought of it.

About these ads

11 Responses

  1. Interesting review. I can’t say I was overly attracted to this book in the first place, but after reading your review, I think I’ll give it a pass.

  2. Thanks for the honest review. I passed on this one because I have a hard time reading cancer stories. You’d think if the mother cared enough to tell her daughters these things before she died, there’d be more affection in the letters.–Anna< HREF="http://diaryofaneccentric.blogspot.com/" REL="nofollow">Diary of an Eccentric<>

  3. This book has a great premise – it’s too bad it didn’t work well for you.

  4. I read this quite a while ago and I remember liking it. I think I do remember though thinking if you were going to leave your children with anything it would be truly personal letters. I still really enjoy Noble’s writing though. I’ve read a couple others and liked them all.I see you’re tackling the blog change. It’s really easy hey. I like it because now when I’m bored I’ll just change up my background and colors and I’m off.

  5. I had to go back and look at my review to see what I thought of this, I guess it didn’t leave a big impression! I liked it enough, it’s a pretty light read despite the material. I wouldn’t necessarily recommend it, I suppose.

  6. Yeah–it sounds like you had the same feelings as I did with Big Fish–who is the story for. I liked your comment about not liking the main character, Barbara. Allowing myself to not like a character and to be able to vocalize that dislike is something I am new at doing. I find it kind of freeing! ;)*smiles and glad you got your power back on. We lose power several times a year and I find it oh-so-annoying.*Kim

  7. I finished this while we were away last week. An “unplugged” vacation, so I couldn’t call in to the interview show.My thoughts are pretty in line with yours … I’ll post my review this coming week.

  8. This one has been on my list for a while..simply because I loved the Reading Group… but it sounds a little sad.. can’t imagine writing those types of letters to my kids…but I have always thought it would be a nice thing to do. Tough subject.

  9. I’ve always avoided this book because of the whole mother dying and leaving her kids behind premise. It just makes me so sad.

  10. […] by Judith R. Hendricks Dreams From My Father by Barack Obama The Sum of Our Days by Isabel Allende Things I Want My Daughters To Know by Elizabeth Noble Let’s Get Fancy Together! by Jane O’Connor The Terror by Dan Simmons […]

  11. […] Hendricks 54. Dreams From My Father by Barack Obama 55. The Sum of Our Days by Isabel Allende 56. Things I Want My Daughters To Know by Elizabeth Noble 57. Let’s Get Fancy Together! by Jane O’Connor 58. The Terror by Dan Simmons […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 542 other followers

%d bloggers like this: